Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Martha's avatar

I love to read your outpouring of love for My Friends because I have it on my shelf to read imminently - meditative and overflowing in humanity are two writing styles that mean a lot to me. I have always loosely been interested in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn and this review has confirmed that interest!

I am waiting for James to come out in paperback and I am intrigued by your reflections. You are the first person I have seen be slightly critical of James (and I love that) because so far, I have only read reviews giddy with admiration. It has left me feeling apprehensive to read it - but now I feel more ready! You’ve given me more meat to think about and I really appreciate that. Everett is a star writer and I like The Trees parallel you’ve made because I enjoyed that book a lot.

I definitely recommend going from the top again with Butlers trilogy! I read it back to back and it is a reading experience I recommend to everyone. I felt an enormous sense of loss when I finished Adulthood Rites. Someone close to me has Parkinson’s and I thought Piñeiro’s depiction was perfection - especially the structure. I thought the book taking place across a singular day was genius because days do feel so long when you have no control over your body.

I have always wanted to read The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating - and as someone with a chronic illness myself, I am really interested in the comfort you describe.

A great (two) months! I really look forward to your review of The Last Warner Woman as someone who has recently read their first Miller. This signals the end of all of my thoughts - thank you for a great read!

Expand full comment
Tasnim's avatar

I really want to read My Friends so I’m glad to hear you speak so highly of it! Also, I read Elena Knows a couple of years ago now but her depiction of living with PD has stayed with me to this day. Incredible writing.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts